Which one is better, the alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB or Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB? We did a deep-dive comparison categorised by purpose of use!
Created date: 2019-03-19 05:05:26, Updated date: 2020-04-16 18:12:42
How are the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" different? We have tested and evaluated their differences. We also explain which one may be best for you.
Contents
- 1.What is the difference between the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"? See a detailed comparison of ease of use and performance
- 1-1.Comparison of weight and size of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
- 1-2.Compare the display of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
- 1-3.Compare the camera performances of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
- 1-4.Comparison of the processing capabilities of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
- 1-5.Comparison of the battery life of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
- 1-6.Compare the storage capacity of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
- 2.Which to buy, the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" or "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
- 3.What are the spec differences between the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" ?
What is the difference between the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"? See a detailed comparison of ease of use and performance
Comparison of weight and size of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
The design of Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB
The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is 163.6mm long, 75.0mm wide, and 8.8mm thick. It weighs 205.0g.
The design of alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB
The "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" is 153.9mm long, 75.4mm wide, and 7.0mm thick. It weighs 152.0g.
Which is the better design to use?
In comparison, the size difference is 9.6mm in length, 0.4mm in width, and 1.8mm in thickness. Both the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" are equally easy to use with one hand. Hiragana flick input is basically just as easy to use with "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB". Both the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" are basically equally portable and easy to handle.
The difference in weight is 53g. The "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" is much lighter, putting less burden on the hand.
Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB | alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB | |
---|---|---|
Ease of holding it in one hand | 63/100 | 65/100 |
How much it does not feel heavy to hold in one hand | 16/100 | 51/100 |
Ease of carrying around | 59/100 | 60/100 |
Compare the display of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
Display of the Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB
The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" uses a AMOLED liquid crystal. The resolution is 1080 x 2340, and the pixel density is 403ppi. The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has a 6.39inch screen size.
Display of the alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB
The "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" uses a AMOLED liquid crystal. The resolution is 1080 x 1920, and the pixel density is 400ppi. The "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" has a 5.5inch screen size.
Which has a better screen?
This makes a 0.88inch difference in the display sizes. Lining up the displays side by side makes the difference in size clearly visible. "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has a bigger display that is easier to use, especially for looking things up on the Internet and using social media. Both the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" can be easily used for this kind of purpose. If you compare how well the different phones support mobile games, the display size of "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" makes it more suited for playing games. Both the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" can be easily used for this kind of purpose.
There is very little difference in the clarity of the displays of "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" when used for research, gaming, or other similar purposes. When using the smartphone as a VR, the screen is generally held much closer to the face than when using the smartphone for other purposes, and so the clarity of the screen becomes a rather important factor. When you compare how easy it is to see the VR on the two phones, it is pretty much the same.
Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB | alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB | |
---|---|---|
How suited is the screen for usual usage? | 79/100 | 72/100 |
How suited is the screen to play games on? | 83/100 | 73/100 |
Compare the camera performances of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
Camera performance of Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB
The main camera of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has 48.0MP. The front camera has 20.0MP.
Camera performance of alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB
The main camera of the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" has 21.0MP. The front camera has 8.0MP.
Which camera performance is better?
The back cameras thus have a 27MP difference in comparison. As for taking photos of scenic places or group photos of people, the rear camera of "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is more suited for capturing distant objects. Also, when using the rear camera to snap close shots of photogenic sweets or meals, there is very little difference between the pixel counts of the two phones. Both the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" can be easily used for this kind of purpose.
There is a 12MP difference in front camera pixel number. The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB"'s front camera also works terrifically well with selfie sticks and for capturing distant objects like the background scenery in your selfies. The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has the necessary specs for this kind of purpose. The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB"'s front camera has a more suitable megapixel count for shooting objects up close for selfies and such.
Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB | alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB | |
---|---|---|
Is is suited to taking far away objects with the rear camera? | 100/100 | 92/100 |
Is it suited for taking close objects with the built-in camera? | 100/100 | 80/100 |
Comparison of the processing capabilities of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
The processing capability of the Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB
Performance is defined by the chipset, and the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" uses the Qualcomm SM8150 Snapdragon 855 SoC. The CPU performance is 2.84GHz+2.42GHz+1.78GHz×8(8.0-cores). The memory capacity is 12.0GB.
The processing capability of the alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB
Performance is defined by the chipset, and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" uses the Qualcomm MSM8996 Snapdragon 820 SoC. The CPU performance is 2.15GHz+1.6GHz×4(4.0-cores). The memory capacity is 4.0GB.
Which has the better processing capability?
As compared to the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB", the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" boasts boasts a better CPU and specs. This is a 8GB difference in memory capacity. The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has more memory storage, making the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" work better for multitasking or running 3D games.
For those who only use their phone's basic features like emailing, instant messaging, or social media, the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is the better choice to buy over the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB". Users looking for a phone to meet their web browsing and video playing needs, with the occasional game every now and then, should definitely go for the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB". The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has the necessary specs for this kind of purpose.
The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" runs 2D games and simple 3D games much more smoothly, making it the better choice in this area. Complex, full-fledged 3D games definitely run better on the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" than the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB". The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has the necessary specs for this kind of purpose.
Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB | alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB | |
---|---|---|
Review on the CPU capbility and memory capacity when using Social Networks or the Internet | 100/100 | 77/100 |
Review on the CPU speed and the memory capacity while playing 3D games | 99/100 | 60/100 |
Comparison of the battery life of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
Battery performance of Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB
The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has a battery capacity of 4000.0mAh.
Battery performance of alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB
The "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" has a battery capacity of 3000.0mAh.
Which battery perfomances is better?
This makes a difference in battery capacity of 1000mAh, but it is not enough to only compare the capacity. With a high-performance CPU, the battery drains faster, and a larger screen also uses more battery.
The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is also a great choice for those who only use their phone for occasional phone calls or for checking the time. For people who tend to use their phone for looking up things on the internet, checking up on social media, or playing the occasional game, I recommend the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" over the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB". Both the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" can be easily used for this kind of purpose.
The battery life of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is well equipped to handle long hours of gaming, video playback, and other kinds of frequent daily use. Both the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" can be easily used for this kind of purpose.
Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB | alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB | |
---|---|---|
Review on the battery life of a phone mainly using Social Networks and the Internet | 100/100 | 87/100 |
Review on the battery life of a phone mainly using mainly games and videos | 100/100 | 74/100 |
Compare the storage capacity of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
The storage capacity of the Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB
The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" has 256.0GB of internal memory.
The storage capacity of the alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB
The "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" has 64.0GB of internal memory. It is also compatible with SD cards, so when there is insufficient storage space, then a SD card can be used to add more storage. A SD with a maximum of 1024.0GB can be used.
Which has the easier storage to use?
The difference in internal memory is about 192GB. "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is recommended if you are using your phone mainly for downloading games and using apps such as social media. Avid gamers should look to the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" for fulfilling their storage needs, as the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" unfortunately falls behind here. Both the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" can be easily used for this kind of purpose.
Because the speed of loading from or saving to the SD card is slow, it is suited for saving pictures or videos.
Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB | alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB | |
---|---|---|
Review on the storage capacity when playing many games | 90/100 | 84/100 |
Review on when you store many pictures and videos | - | 96/100 |
Which to buy, the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" or "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"
At the end of the day which is better, the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" or "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB"?
If you're looking for something that's easy to hold, the compact "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" is a great choice. If you want a larger screen, "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is recommended as it has a 6.39inch screen. The "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" also hands down has the superior specs. When comparing "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" overall, "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is a more balanced model and is recommended.
Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB | alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB | |
---|---|---|
Handling | 49/100 | 60/100 |
Display | 80/100 | 74/100 |
CPU specs | 99/100 | 67/100 |
General rating | 84/100 | 74/100 |
Is it recommended to buy the Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB, compared with other smartphones?
Compared to other smartphones, the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is averagely easy to hold. Although it can be a little difficult, it is the right size to be able to operate with one hand. The screen size is larger than that of standard smartphones. It is suited for typing long texts and so can be used to read or edit office texts. In addition, its processing capability is quite excellent compared to the average smart phone. It is suitable for almost all uses, including games and VR. It may be a bit extravagant for normal use. Looking at the overall specifications, the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" is a high-end smart phone.
Want to read it together
Is it recommended to buy the alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB, compared with other smartphones?
Compared to other smart phones, the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" has a size that is easy to hold, and looks compact. It can be easily operated with one hand. The screen size is larger than that of standard smartphones. It is suited for typing long texts and so can be used to read or edit office texts. In addition, its processing capabilities are of a slightly higher specification compared to the average smart phone, and can be said to be more than adequate for normal use. However, its performance may feel slightly inadequate when playing 3D games and such. Looking at the overall specifications, the "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" is a middle-range to high-end smart phone.
Want to read it together
What are the spec differences between the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB" ?
A summary of the technical specifications of the "Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB" and "alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB". Functions and performance variations on the same model will be highlighted in red.
Xiaomi Black Shark 2 256GB | alcatel Idol 4s Windows 64GB | |
Color | Black/Silver/Blue | Halo Gold |
OS | Android | Windows |
Dimensions (width x height x thickness) | 75.0mm x 163.6mm x 8.8mm | 75.4mm x 153.9mm x 7.0mm |
Weight | 205.0g | 152.0g |
Display size | 6.39inch | 5.5inch |
Display type | AMOLED | AMOLED |
Screen resolution (width x height) | 1080 x 2340 | 1080 x 1920 |
Pixel density | 403ppi | 400ppi |
Battery capacity | 4000.0mAh | 3000.0mAh |
Chipset | Qualcomm SM8150 Snapdragon 855 | Qualcomm MSM8996 Snapdragon 820 |
CPU specs | 2.84GHz+2.42GHz+1.78GHz×8(8.0-cores) | 2.15GHz+1.6GHz×4(4.0-cores) |
RAM size | 12.0GB | 4.0GB |
Storage size | 256.0GB | 64.0GB |
Rear-camera resolution | 48.0MP | 21.0MP |
Front-camera resolution | 20.0MP | 8.0MP |
Look at a smartphone Compare smartphones | Look at a smartphone Compare smartphones |